Thursday, September 16, 2010

Marzano Chapter 3

Name: Summer Searls
Reading Research Notebook
Marzano Chapter 3
Strategy: Summarizing and Note Taking

Part 1: Summary
                In chapter 3, Marzano emphasizes the importance of summarizing and note taking in the classroom. He begins by a situation in which a teacher wants her students to summarize and take notes and comes to find that the students are unaware of how to really do these techniques. The author explains the importance of first teaching students good habits and things to remember while summarizing and note taking. The three vital processes to remember include deleting some information, substituting some information, and retaining or keeping some information. These three rules allow students to effectively summarize as well as think about the content at a deeper level. This is because they are determining what important and useful information is and what is not. Marzano then explains that the “rule-based” strategy as well as summary frames aid in good practicing techniques for summarizing in the classroom. For note taking, the author declares that verbatim note taking is highly ineffective, notes should be a student’s own work for a study guide, and one can never take too many notes. Marzano offers research to support these claims. Marzano ends the chapter be passionately asserting that note taking and studying are much more than just study skills. He says these tools are “two of the most powerful skills students can cultivate” (p.48).
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
                When reading this chapter, my mind immediately went back to chapter 3 in our other textbook. In this chapter, the authors are discussing procedural knowledge. On page 79 in The Art and Science of Student Teaching, the authors state that the end goal of procedural knowledge is fluency. They say “without fluency, procedural knowledge is not very useful” (p79). This relates hand-in-hand with note taking and summarizing. These skills are procedural knowledge that is highly important to students’ study habits and skills. As teachers, our goal should be to get students to the place where note taking and summarizing become fluent. Once fluency has been reached with these skills, students will have a deepened knowledge about the content because they will be able to better understand and better process the knowledge given to them.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
                I found this chapter to be very interesting. I have always known that in a science classroom there will be times that students must take notes and summarize some things from lectures or text books. However, I never really considered the importance behind the process of note taking and summarizing. I somewhat just believed these skills to be merely study skills. Now I realize how important these are to students. After reading this chapter, I feel that I have some ideas and methods that would be useful in my classroom. As far as summarizing methods, I would prefer the “rule-based” strategy in my classroom. This is because, in science, I will either be lecturing, having them experiment or do some kind of hands on learning, or asking them to read from their text books. Since a textbook would be the only thing they would read I feel this is the best way to teach summarizing. Give them “rules” of steps to follow that would allow them to summarize important information. For note taking I would probably start the students out with teacher prepared notes and slowly move to having them create their own notes. It is important in science that the student is experimenting, learning, and making observations. These are not things that I can always tell them to write down. For example, they could observe something that is important to them but maybe not to another group. No matter what method is used, summarizing and note taking are essential in a science class.

2 comments:

  1. I agree that summarizing and note taking are very important in a science classroom because so many concepts are discussed; there are so many CSOs that have to be covered so the science classroom can be fast paced at times and students can get lost. If they are taught the proper way to take notes and summarize, they can get more benefit from it and learning can take place.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the idea of the rules and steps to follow when summarizing. Students sometimes needs a push in the right direction. I also love the idea of the teacher prepared notes and then slowing moving them to their own notes. It allows students to learn how to do and then given the chance to do it themselves which is a great way to learn.

    ReplyDelete