Name: Summer Searls
Reading Research Notebook
Marzano Chapter 2
Strategy: Identifying Similarities and Differences
Part 1: Summary
In chapter two, Marzano focuses on the importance of similarities and differences in our classroom strategies today. Marzano exclaims that similarities and differences “might be considered the core of all learning” (p 14) The text reveals research that shows that by students understanding similarities and differences, hard and difficult problems can quickly become easy and obvious. Once students can grasp the ideas of similarities and differences they can use this knowledge to better understand the new material being covered. Presenting students with guidance in identifying similarities and differences and asking them to identify them independently are two theories that the research also provided. It is important to aid the students to some extent; however, by them exploring similarities and differences on their own, they are given a chance to make the subject more meaningful to them and thus, they can gain a deeper understanding. In presenting similarities and differences, research explains that four forms are highly effective in the classroom. These four forms include comparing characteristics, classifying material, creating metaphors, and creating analogies. Each idea mentioned aides in accomplishing the tasks of presenting similarities and differences in the classroom.
Part 2: Connection of reading to another reading in class
In chapter 3 of our text book The Art and Science of Teaching the chapter begins by explaining that metaphors are a more abstract level of thinking. I would connect this to chapter 2 because metaphors are one of the ways to present similarities and differences. It is evident that this should be at a higher level of thinking because children gain more knowledge and understanding by doing it. On pages 59 and 60 in chapter 3, the author discusses schema development. After reading Marzano’s chapter 2, I made the connection that schema development is basically how similarities and differences work. Schema development occurs when either new information is learned or when new material is attached or built onto pre-existing material in the mind. This is exactly what similarities and differences are trying to accomplish. Schema development and similarities and differences work hand-in-hand in developing students’ knowledge to deepen and grow.
Part 3: Application of reading to my own teaching interests
I feel that in this chapter there are many ideas on similarities and differences I can take and use in my classroom. In a science classroom, I have seen Venn diagrams used often for comparing and classifying items or concepts. I believe that this particular example of presenting similarities and differences is great because it allows the students to mentally think of each item being discussed and causes them to visually see the similarities and differences by putting them into a diagram. Also, creating analogies is another strategy I will take to my classroom. I like this idea because it can allow the students to make a deeper connection with the new material by comparing to something they already know. It can also be useful because I, as the teacher, could use it for an across the curriculum activity. For example, I could say Babe Ruth is to ball bat as Galileo is to______. And the answer would be telescope. I could make science fun and understandable by connecting the topic to something that interests them or something they already know. Also, they could create their own analogies. This would allow me to know that the student has the concept and also show me what they are interested in or already have connections to. No matter which method I chose to use the most, Marzano has proven to me that similarities and differences must be shown in the classroom. The research has shown me that by presenting similarities and differences students gain a much deeper knowledge and understanding of the material being covered. Similarities and differences will definitely be used in my classroom.
It is very important to stress similarities and differences when teaching content in the science classroom. I like how you suggested the use of a diagram; this would be good to use for visual learners. I also like the use of analogies. Analogies allow the students to remember the connection between two concepts. Research has shown significant percentile gains when using the strategy of identifying similarities and differences.
ReplyDeleteI like how you are using the idea of analogies. It is great using something a student already knows and associating it with a new concept. I agree with you that presenting similarities and differences in a some way student gain more knowledge and learn more.
ReplyDeleteReally love the ideas about analogies and I liked the example with Babe Ruth. I agree that with science, comparisons like this are essential bceasue so many of the concepts are tough to get a real grasp on in your mind.
ReplyDeleteI like how you all mention the importance of analogies to relate difficult concepts to students. I also agree that using diagrams to relate similarities and differences in science are beneficial for students.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comments!
Dr.C.